No interim order on IGP appointment

  • Get News Alerts

The Supreme Court (SC) hearing the writ petition filed by DIG Nava Raj Silwal against appointment of Prakash Aryal as the IGP of Nepal Police has refused to issue an Interim Order as demanded by the petitioner. The single bench of Justice Ishwor Prasad Khatiwada on Wednesday, however, has asked the government to give reasons about why Aryal was appointed.

Silwal had moved the Apex Court on Tuesday, a day after Aryal's appointment, claiming that he is above three others, who were in contention for the top post, in terms of seniority and performance evaluation. He had also submitted comparison of performance evaluation of him and Aryal for the past four years in the petition.

Silwal had 148 points and Aryal 147 out of 150 in the fiscal year 2069/70, according to the details Silwal submitted. The duo secured equal points—36, 39 and 40 each out of 40—in the subsequent three years. Silwal secured a total of 263 points and Aryal 262, according to the submitted details.

Quoting the SC verdict that had directed the government to pick the one who is senior and has secured the highest points in performance evaluation over four years, Silwal has argued in his petition that the government does not have authority to again pick and choose, and called the appointment arbitrary.

The government on Monday had appointed DIG Aryal as IGP. The cabinet meeting filled the post that had remained vacant after the SC canceled promotion of Jai Bahadur Chand on March 21.

A full bench including Chief Justice Sushila Karki and justices Hari Krishna Karki, Ishwor Prasad Khatiwada, Ananda Mohan Bhattarai and Anil Kumar Bhattarai had ordered the government to appoint another IGP from among qualified contenders.

It had directed the government to consider performance evaluation of the contenders for the past four fiscal years and appoint the one who has performed the best on an average during the period.

The Home Ministry had sent the files of performance of the four contenders to the cabinet for making the appointment. The cabinet then formed a four-member committee including secretaries at the Prime Minister's Office, Home Ministry and Law Ministry, and acting IGP of Nepal Police to evaluate performance of the contenders before making the appointment. The committee deemed Aryal to have topped the contenders in terms of performance.

Aryal secured 154.2 points, Silwal, one of the petitioners against appointment of Chand, 152.4, Bam Bahadur Bhandari 150.2 and Chand 147.6.

The government on February 12 had promoted the fourth-ranked contender among the quartet of DIGs—Silwal, Aryal, Chand, and Bhandari--all of whom were in contention for the top job due to the unflinching backing of Nepali Congress (NC) President Sher Bahadur Deuba.

The single bench of Chief Justice Sushila Karki hearing a pre-emptive writ petition filed by advocate Kapil Dev Dhakal had ordered the government not to implement the cabinet’s decision just a few hours after Chand's appointment. She again issued the same instruction the following day hearing a petition filed by Silwal.

The government had made AIG Dr Dinesh Chandra Pokharel from technical service the acting chief of Nepal Police amending the Nepal Police Regulations while the case was sub judice. The amendment was made for one time appointment of AIG from technical service acting IGP.

Comments

More News

  • Federal Alliance, UDMF withdraw all protest programs

    The Federal Alliance and United Democratic Madhesi Front (UDMF) have withdrawn all the protest programs which they had announced earlier. “The joint meeting of FA and Madhesi Front has called off withdrawn all the protest programs following the agreement reached with the government late Saturday,” said Co-chairman of Federal Socialist Forum Rajendra Shrestha.

  • No poll after budget: UML

    No poll after budget: UML The parliamentary party meeting of CPN-UML Sunday afternoon has concluded that the local election cannot be held after the annual budget is presented in the parliament. The meeting, that ended shortly after the Cabinet decided to hold the polls on May 14 and June 14, has decided that the party will not accept presentation of the annual budget in a way to influence the election.

  • RPP to forge alliance with like-minded parties for election

    RPP to forge alliance with like-minded parties for election The Rastriya Prajatantra Party (RPP) is to forge alliance with parties carrying similar ideology and principle in the local level elections. The election has been scheduled for May 14.

  • House meeting postponed for Monday

    House meeting postponed for Monday The meeting of the parliament scheduled for Sunday afternoon has been postponed until Monday 1:00 PM. The meeting was to start at 3:00 pm.

  • Local election on May 14 and June 14

    Local election on May 14 and June 14 The Cabinet meeting on Sunday has decided to hold local election on May 14 and June 14 as per the agreement reached with the United Democratic Madhesi Front (UDMF) Saturday evening to hold the polls in two stages.

Opinion

  • Challenges for reconstruction Challenges for reconstruction

    One of the major challenges faced in the reconstruction process of Nepal is the absence of elected local government. Lack of government in local level was reflected in the major pre-disaster and post-disaster events, where it took months to reach the affected region and still no widely-accepted data is available. In the absence of an elected local government, top-down approach of governance has its own accountability deficit.

    Apil KC/Keshab Sharma

  • Making sense of Adityanath's rise in Modi's India Making sense of Adityanath's rise in Modi's India

    The most notorious incitement of communal hatred by Adityanath was his exhortation to 'kill ten woh log ['them' meaning Muslims]' rather than knocking the doors of legal system 'if one Hindu is killed' in riots.

    Jiwan Kshetry

Blog

  • Identity and nationhood Identity and nationhood

    Whoever says nationhood is not important would be lying. For example, belonging to a particular nation may give certain advantages to a person that one belonging to another nation would not get.

    Ketan Dulal

  • The shankha blower from Bichour The shankha blower from Bichour

    Coincidentally, Ram Lal Joshi, the Radio Nepal singer had his house adjacent to ours and had been hearing him blow it every day. Hari worked as a bagainche in Singha-durbar during day. Ram Lal got him to blow the shankha as a part of musical instrument for Radio Nepal’s iconic signature tune.

    Hemant Arjyal

Readers Column

  • Traffic Police in Kathmandu

    As busy and hassling as the traffic system in Kathmandu is, the Traffic Police here have to handle an equally strenuous job. Over 1,400 traffic officers in and around the Kathmandu Valley battle against the pestering traffic and air pollution each day.

  • Menstrual taboo outdated

    I have seen my sisters and friends isolated and treated in discriminatory manner during their first menstruation cycle. They were not allowed to look at the sun, to touch water source, flower, fruits, any male family member, nor even hear their voice. The activist may claim the situation has changed and I do agree but still during every month my loved ones turns into untouchables beings.

Popular

Recommended

Suchanapati