SC moved demanding revocation of decision to not test vegetables for pesticides

The Supreme Court (SC) has been moved demanding immediate revocation of the government’s decision to stop testing Indian fruits and vegetables for pesticides.

Advocates Swagat Nepal and Narayan Prasad Duwadi on behalf of Independent National Campaign have filed the writ petition in the SC arguing that the government cannot take a decision in a way that people are forced to consume vegetables and fruits with pesticides merely because the state cannot test them for now.

The petitioners demand that vegetables be brought from India only after test for pesticides and domestic vegetables also be sold in the market only after tests. They argue that the government’s decision compromises the rights of consumers, right to health, safe motherhood and other rights enshrined in the Constitution.

The petition points that consumption of food with pesticides by pregnant women harm the fetus and violates the rights to health and safe motherhood.

The government had made testing of Indian fruits and vegetables for pesticides mandatory from the third week of June publishing a notice in the Nepal Gazette.
India had taken exception to testing of Indian fruits and vegetables for pesticides at the border. Writing a letter to top government officials, the Indian Embassy in Kathmandu had expressed concern at the checking.
The testing has been stopped for now citing lack of adequate preparations after that.

The petition claims that the Cabinet cannot take decision in that manner. “The Constitution says the fundamental rights mentioned in it will be implemented gradually formulating laws. The notice was published in the Nepal Gazette as the law cannot be formulated immediately,” advocate Nepal said. “The Cabinet cannot annul the notice published in the Nepal Gazette to implement the fundamental rights even by publishing another notice in the Nepal Gazette.”

The government has been widely criticized for stepping back on the issue related to public health under Indian pressure.
Minister for Industry, Commerce and Supplies Matrika Yadav has conceded that he erred in making test of Indian fruits and vegetables for pesticides without building capacity, and apologized for that.
Organizing a press conference at the ministry on Monday, he claimed that he made the mistake as the secretaries did not brief him thoroughly while advising him. He apologized for the mistake and stated that the immature decision was taken due to advice by four secretaries.



© 2017 Setopati Sanchar Pvt. Ltd.